Featured

Welcome

Never underestimate the power of a small group of committed people to change the world. In fact, it is the only thing that ever has.

— Margaret Mead.

I am creating and developing this site to create a space for information for parents and guardians of students currently attending York Memorial Collegiate Institute. By doing this (on my own) I intend to manage the information in a more timely and relevant manner than would be otherwise available. All opinions are mine.

Let’s start with the obvious – NONE of us want to be here…and by “here” I mean in the position of advocating for our students, teachers and school after:

  • suffering the loss of our building on May 6 & 7, 2019, and our personal items
  • the subsequent rapid re-settlement at George Harvey Collegiate Institute in a dual-school format
  • advocating for re-location at Scarlett Heights (15 Trehorne, Etobicoke)
  • receiving the Initial Staff Report for the Modified Pupil Review (January 29, 2020)

And yet, here we are.

I believe we, the parents and guardians of York Memo students, deserve to be heard and seen in a process that has already been created to limit our voice. We are a diverse and somewhat chaotic group – but I feel that we can unite and work together to influence the path our future school may take. The time is NOW, the Board gears have already begun to turn…

PAUSE

On Friday, March 13th, our students were released to March Break; however, the day before the Ontario government had announced an extension of the break until April 5th. The provincial government announcement was directly related to the World Health Organization declaration that SARS-CoV-2 (virus) had now spread and the disease COVID-19 was at a pandemic level.

What does this mean? It means that people in the world are getting sick (and dying) and governments are fighting to try to protect their peoples’ health, welfare and financial situations while at the same time trying to save economies.

What does it mean for this PAR? Since everything surrounding this virus is changing rapidly, it makes sense that this issue should not be a priority…BUT….the TDSB has had its first Virtual Board Meeting – which suggests that they are working from home and are attempting to keep things moving business-wise. At this moment, I can guess that the priority will be trying to figure out how teachers (still without contracts as unions) will or can deliver the remaining school year despite socio-economic and other inequities between family supports and families. There are A LOT of factors to be considered.

But I will close out this blog now (put it on “pause”) until we know more. Currently, the meeting with the Alumni from both schools, and the meeting with the feeder elementary school folks have been cancelled. This is what we KNOW. If the Board is able to meet (virtually), and staff are still getting paid to work my belief is the PAR will continue…but there will be even LESS opportunities to participate in the futures of these schools.

– Bye for now…D

Transit-led Development

When my son started school at York Memorial, the Crosstown LRT was already under construction on Eglinton. I do not recall what the building looked like before the construction happened, so I must not have noticed the last time I lived here. Why does this matter? The future of the school and schools in this neighbourhood are tied to the changes that will come with having this system in place.

The TDSB Initial Staff Report (and last year’s reports) relied heavily on the “THE THREE CITIES WITHIN TORONTO – Income Polarization Among Toronto’s Neighbourhoods, 1970-2005” Report (or “The Three Cities” Report) by J. David Hulchanski. The flaw in using this report as a predictor, especially for this neighbourhood, lies in the fact that the predictions (which project to 2025) do NOT include any information related to the Crosstown LRT simply because the report was updated in 2007 with 2006 Census Data.

A somewhat more relevant, but highly controversial report provides some insight into possible changes to the future of this neighbourhood: EglintonConnects. More specifically, this report outlines a plan for “revitalization” of specific neighbourhoods – making them more appealing to new investors, families seeking something away from the downtown core, etc. I will not dwell on the looming effects on the current neighbourhood which serves its families and community, but it is necessary to comment on the current reality: the extended construction and the increasing corporate taxes in advance of the Crosstown make it increasingly difficult for businesses to stay open and leave the neighbourhood vulnerable to speculative development and rezoning which will certainly increase population density in this neighbourhood.

This is fact: there are AT LEAST three condominium developments being built within 1.1 km of these schools. One building will be located about 250 metres away from the York Memorial location on Eglinton. This building is designed to be 14 stories high with units from 1-3 bedrooms – 216 units.

Keele/Eglinton Developments – 2020

A common argument made during PARs is that “neighbourhoods will be turning over” and this has been trivialized in the past – in this case, the Crosstown LRT has targeted this area, and the assumption that population/age density in the area will not be changing is WRONG. It is already changing…and decisions related to the futures of these schools must work with more current data – including adjusting projections of declining enrollment to reflect this information.

Loss and Grief

The five stages – denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance – are a part of the framework that makes up our learning to live with the one we lost. They are tools to help us frame and identify what we may be feeling. But they are not stops on some linear timeline in grief.

Elisabeth Kubler-Ross
Source: https://psychcentral.com/lib/the-5-stages-of-loss-and-grief/

We, as a community, suffered a huge loss in the May 6-7 fire(s). Some individuals in the community suffered more than others and the process to “keep moving” invalidated their legitimate feelings of the experience. THE TOLL IS VISIBLE.

Grief is a process – no one can decide how it impacts another. It is individual. We know there are supports for those who are able to see what they are experiencing – but not everyone relates the feelings with the source. Not everyone is able to relate the loss of a building and “stuff” to something that would trigger a grief process, but this is well documented.

When doing research on this connection I found an article on the effects of the Fort McMurray wildfires on students – some of the information of this study can directly apply to the students, teachers and staff in this situation. Sadly, no one wanted to look at this issue during our process to get to our current location.

Using the fire impact information, coupled with the community responses that have been well documented during other Pupil Accommodation Reviews, the indications are that a PAR is heavily impacted by the grief process. The responses from our community reflect the levels of grief we are experiencing – denial, anger, bargaining, depression…. but the TIMING of the experience in a modified PAR indicate that very few of us will actually get to “acceptance” by the time the Trustees vote. The mental health impact will be the legacy of this Board of Trustees.

Something Smells…

I got the text from my son while I was at work – something no parent wants to read: “…the school is on fire”. Knowing that there was likely to be a school follow-up, when he came home we just waited to hear. He kept following on his social media. When the information came out about 7 pm that the fire was out, we both breathed a sigh of relief.

UNTIL THE NEXT MORNING…

I was worried, and I woke up early to check headlines…only to find out that the school was on fire AGAIN – a “second” fire. This one was bigger, and consumed the auditorium and parts of the main building, particularly on the upper floor. Here is how one media outlet covered it: https://globalnews.ca/news/5248385/second-fire-york-memorial-ci/

The school situation aside, from a personal perspective, we were dealing with the loss of expensive items in the fire. We knew the items that were in the classroom had been lost, but we had additional items in another, seemingly untouched part of the building. School officials had us log in our losses, and we were told that some of the items may be returned. So we waited…

And we waited…

And we waited…

And we waited…

We waited to hear word on our items, and we waited to hear about the cause of the fire. In actual fact, other fires happened in the city and fire reports were made BUT OURS took much longer.

Nearly four months after the fire(s) occurred, we were given the following information: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/york-memorial-memo-fire-cause-1.5264889 . After the long wait, the report seemed….less than expected.

Like the ruins of our once beautiful, historic Grande Dame of a building, something “smells”.

From the field side

May 6-7, 2019

I don’t think I could adequately express what those days were like…and unless you have been through it, you can’t quite understand. It was tumultuous, scary, and a huge shock. And a TREMENDOUS loss to this community.

The aftermath of rumour and speculation, lack of certainty, and the prolonged failure to deliver accurate, empathetic information to the school community was harmful. At the very least, failure to follow-up with the community to provide appropriate psychological supports (likely due to lack of funding) was an significant oversight. The opportunity to document the effects of the fire on the school population has been lost.

I tried my best to convey the effects in my Delegation at the Committee of the Whole Meeting on June 12, 2019. The full text is posted in the Reference section of this blog.

Responsibilities of Leadership

Sometimes, it falls upon a leader to do the “difficult thing” – to be honest and upfront about a situation. Very few people like to be “surprised” by bad information (perceived or otherwise) so it is a wise leader who knows and takes responsibility for preparing the audience. One such important document related specifically to THIS work is the following:

The document in its entirety can be found via this link: http://bit.ly/dewg2009 . While the document is now over a decade old, there are some key points in it which relate to the current situation – and ignoring the recommendations MADE OVER TEN YEARS AGO seems rather foolish as the relevant reactions are not likely to have changed.

This image was taken directly from the report:

DEWG Report, page 36

“…declining enrolment is “the elephant in the room,” a difficult subject that no one wants to discuss. This situation especially prevails when a school closure or consolidation is under consideration. These situations will never be easy to resolve, but communities need to be aware of all aspects of the issue in order to contribute to and respect a soundly
based decision. They must understand the significant costs as well as the benefits involved. For example, the costs of keeping an underutilized school open could divert resources from programs and services that promote student achievement. Whether a school closure is at issue or not, better information will help to build understanding. Usually the status quo is not an option.”

DEWG Report, page 34

My challenge is this: going forward into the future leadership must be prepared to make the hard choices and face the difficult discussions. By not being in conversation with our school communities, by initiating the modified Pupil Accommodation Review – under a moratorium – using our tragedy as “special circumstances”, those who say they are looking out for us have put our healing community into crisis. The expectation that this could happen is well documented and could have been avoided – and the opportunity for courageous leadership is now lost.

Why This Hurts

2019-2020

I am a visual learner, so in trying to make sense of why this is so distressing to so many I began looking at the timeline of events. The Infographic to the right is the timeline so far…the last two points are the beginnings of the process for modified Pupil Accommodation Review.

I am not sure who was aware that the Board of Trustees was proceeding on this, but I do know that there are some leaders who failed to let the school community know.

In the Initial Staff Report, the MOE template requires a report on the student well-being and the local community. What the report has failed to include is the impact the process has had in these two areas.

I have begun to gather information on this – and there is much evidence on negative impacts on communities involved in PARs as well as impacts on communities that have experienced trauma.

Stay tuned…

The Case for Scenario 4

Update: Regular Board Meeting, February 5th, ten of us attended the Regular Board Meeting of the TDSB (including the principal). We intentionally dressed in red or wore our York Memorial hoodies so that no one could wonder why we were there. Wisely, this prompted our Ward Trustee Chris Tonks to ask to “bring forward” our Agenda point. By bringing forward our agenda point, we were allowed to witness questions and discussion regarding our requests for a standard Pupil Accommodation Review. Although no Trustee amended the items up for vote, we were able to make public record some additional details. I consider this a “win”. We, as a community, now know their target timeline for the PAR and can plan accordingly.

I need to be honest: it is a huge endeavour to attempt to create change in system that is designed to work a particular way. Fortunately, after all my research, I still feel it is worth fighting. The Board is setting a precedent with this action, and what we do can impact or influence any future PARs.

The Initial Staff Report http://bit.ly/ISR0129 contains very specific language that must be read carefully. The Ministry of Education (MOE) defines what must be included in the Report and the format it must be presented in (in fact, there was a slight delay because the format is SO new that they hadn’t fully developed the template). The MOE is taking school closures very seriously…and this is making the work of the TDSB in this financial climate much more difficult.

There are three Scenarios. Two of the scenarios are not in the least economically viable therefore it is not a surprise that the Board Staff made the bold move of recommending the third:

Initial Staff Report, January 29, 2020

The Staff has outlined the case in the Initial Staff Report, but leaves the opportunity option to consider additional scenarios – THIS IS IMPORTANT. I believe that our new goal as advocates and authors of our own future is to create the case for an additional scenario – Scenario 4:

Our Proposed Scenario

NOTE: The above scenario does not actually exist as yet. The goal is to get the Board Staff to include it in the considerations.

Stay tuned….

Importance of the Regular Meeting, February 5th, 2020

On February 5th, 2020 the TDSB Trustees will be voting on the recommendations proposed in the Initial Staff Report presented on Wednesday, January 29, 2020. The fact that we have had ONE WEEK to process all that is going on is the reason why we, as parents, should be concerned about their plan.

I have asked that any concerned parents write or email the Trustees and request a Standard Pupil Accommodation Review. (Truthfully, I don’t believe we will get one – the Trustees have been requesting a modified PAR since June 8.) At the very least, the Trustees may get an awareness that we are not disinterested or complacent.

Here is a simple visual to explain the difference:

A Simple Visual

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free